Skip to main content

Why is Religion Evil?

Last night I watched the online video of the Christopher Hitchens and Alister McGrath debate. The premise of the debate was centered around the question "Poison or Cure?: Religious Belief in the Modern World." Hitchens' (the author of God is not Great) is that religion leads people to do unspeakable evil. I am afraid that McGrath's (The Dawkin's Delusion) response was not up to the challenge.

Part of the problem, at least how it appeared to me, was that McGrath just wasn't aggressive enough in his response. In other words I don't think that Christianity offers no response, but McGrath wasn't assertive enough to put it out there. It is like the times I have watched my oldest nephew play soccer. His problem isn't that he lacks the skill or the athletic ability, but that he lacks the aggression to get in there in mix it up.

This lack of aggression really showed itself in one key part of the debate when McGrath really could have reversed things and helped us see that the fact that Hitchens says religion is evil and poisons everything is evidence that God exists.

During the question and answer time the first question is directed at Hitchens. The question is: If God does not exist on what basis can anyone say this action is right or this action is wrong? In his response Hitchens eludes the question, instead he focuses on how the religion gives people the divine permission to do evil things. Yet the question remains: Why does he consider these actions evil? What is his basis for declaring them so?

I agree that with many of the things that he deemed evil that have been done, and are being done, in the name of religion (other points I think he misrepresents what the Bible says and Christian theology). For me this gift of morality, the ability to speak of something as right and wrong, is a gift from God confirmed by His Word. But why would Hitchens speak of things of being right or wrong/good or evil?

This is exactly the point C. S. Lewis begins Mere Christianity with. Lewis closes chapter one by writing:
"These, then, are the two points I wanted to make. First, that human beings, all over the earth, have this curious idea that they ought to behave in a certain way, and cannot really get rid of it. Secondly, that they do not in fact behave in that way. They know the Law of Nature, they break it. These two facts are the foundation of all clear thinking about ourselves and the universe we live in." (p. 21)

Lewis tells us that people possess this idea of what is right and wrong naturally. It is part of who we are, and that is why Hitchens can look at these things and declare them evil (with the majority of Christians agreeing with him). So while I would appeal to God being the author of this "Law of Nature", how would Hitchens account for it?

I think this is an important question to be asked because it gets to the basis of why we consider things to be right and wrong. How does nature and natural selection account for the morality that we now possess? If God doesn't exist why should I care to live a moral life, what benefit is it to me? Why should I care about atrocities on the other side of the world if they don't affect me? On what basis can you appeal to me to be moral? All questions to be considered if God doesn't exist.


thekingpin68 said…
Interesting article. I reviewed Lewis and McGrath with my MPhil dissertation which can be found in my blog archives. I am finishing up a PhD dissertation, also on theodicy and my blog contains several related articles. Have a great weekend.

Popular posts from this blog

Prayer: Married Bedtime Prayer

My wife Jenny and I have been using the Bedtime Prayer that John Eldredge wrote for Walking with God as part of our bedtime routine.  As much as I have enjoyed the prayer I thought it was time for a prayer that was better suited to pray together.  Hopefully this will encourage you to implement prayer into your bedtime routine.

Our Father in Heaven, we pause at the end of this day to say thank You.  We give You thanks for the blessing of life, for the blessing of each other, for the blessing of family, and for the blessing of a home. You have richly blessed our lives. Restore us Father to Your Son Jesus.  He is the vine and we are the branches and He has become our source of life.  Open our hearts to receive the Holy Spirit's guidance, healing, and transformation.  May our lives and our marriage bear the fruit of the Spirit.  We surrender our lives and our marriage to You.  You have our bodies, possessions, and spirits; we give You our hearts, souls, minds, and strength.  We belon…

God Uses Unlikely People

One of the things that strike me about God is that the value society has given to people makes no difference to Him. In fact it seems that God would rather use the common, even the despised, people of the world to make a difference in this world. Consider Moses. God doesn’t use Moses when he is a prince of Egypt, but when he is a nomadic shepherd. Certainly God has used the rich and the powerful, but more often than not God has used the poor, sinful, and abused. God uses the unlikeliest people.

This reality comes our loud and clear at Christmas time. Think about the major characters of the Christmas story: Joseph who is a poor and scandalize carpenter, Mary who is a young and scandalized girl, Shepherds who are a bunch of untrustworthy characters. Only the Magi have credibility in society, but this diminishes in Jewish culture since these men were Gentiles. The most important event in the history of the world and God chooses people who are rejected and wouldn’t be believed by so…

Worship is a Lifestyle

"It's a lot easier to sing a song than it is to stop and touch the broken. It's a lot less taxing to go to church than to take 'church' to the world. But sharing with others is a sacrifice of worship that makes God smile." ~ Louie Giglio; The Air I Breathe

Worship isn't just about music. Worship isn't just an activity that is planned and programmed. Worship is about glorifying God with our lives. When we seek to honor God, we worship Him.

Worship happens anytime and anyplace. It happens Sunday mornings at church. It happens Wednesday night at Bible Study. It happens when we chat with our neighbor. It happens when we serve those in need. It happens when we show love to the lonely. Worship is what being a Christian is all about.

Worship is a life lived in response to God's gracious blessings. God has given us so much. We owe Him every breath we breathe. He is responsible for our talents we use. God has given us blessing after blessing. Only a life o…