Pages

Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

Linkage: Secular Theocracy Part Two

You can read part of David Theroux's article here: Secular Theocracy Part 1.

One of the justifications given for the Civil War is that it was done to "perserve the Union."  The death of all those thousands of men are justified because the nation was held together.  Today we are told that we must sacrifice our liberties in order for the Nation to be secure.  It is the United States, especially seen in the Federal government, that is supreme and we must protect it at all costs.  The state religion of the United States is the religion of nationalism.

This is troublesome, not only because of the loss of personal liberty we experience, but the unquestioning loyalty and support people give to those in positions of power.  They after all work for the all powerful state, must they must be right!

During the Enlightenment, nationalism became the new civic religion, in which the nation state was not merely a substitute for the church, but a substitute for God, and political religion benefited from being more tangible than supernatural religion in having the physical means of violence necessary to enforce mandatory worship and funding. Nation states provided a new kind of salvation and immortality; one’s death is not in vain if it is “for the nation,” which will live on. 
This “myth of religious violence” lived on with legal theorist John Rawls who claimed that the modern problem is a theological one and the solution is political. For Rawls, since people believe in unresolvable theological doctrines over which they will kill each other, a secular state must rule. Similarly, Stanford law professor Kathleen Sullivan, a secularist, has claimed that as a necessary condition for peace to avoid a “war of all sects against all,” religion must be banished from the public square.

Continue Reading....

Friday, January 06, 2012

Linkage: Secular Theocracy

We are told that there is a divide between secular and religion.  So we make religion a thing of personal preference and the secular, such as politics and eduction, public.  The problem lies in the reality that there is not such a clean divide.  As any devout religious person will tell you, our faith plays a huge role in the decisions that we make, including where we go to school and who we vote for in elections.  In part one of his article Secular Theocracy David J. Theroux explains how the Enlightenment produced this divide of sacred verses secular, which had never existed before, and gave rise to the tyranny that we now live under: the secular state.
We live in an increasingly secularized world of massive and pervasive nation states in which traditional religion, especially Christianity, is ruled unwelcome and even a real danger on the basis of a purported history of intolerance and “religious violence.” This is found in most all “public” domains, including the institutions of education, business, government, welfare, transportation, parks and recreation, science, art, foreign affairs, economics, entertainment, and the media. A secularized public square policed by government is viewed as providing a neutral, rational, free, and safe domain that keeps the “irrational” forces of religion from creating conflict and darkness. And we are told that real progress requires expanding this domain by pushing religion ever backward into remote corners of society where it has little or no influence. In short, modern America has become a secular theocracy with a civic religion of national politics (nationalism) occupying the public realm in which government has replaced God.

Continue Reading...

Monday, August 24, 2009

Coercion or Compassion?

To be a follower of Christ means to have compassion for people in need. It should break our hearts to see people oppressed, hungry, sick, and lonely. If we are not moved to compassion by the plight of those in need then we have a huge red flag in regards to our relationship with God. That red flag should cause us to examine whether or not we are really following Jesus.

The debate about compassion and loving our neighbor that the Church faces right now doesn’t center on whether or not we should be actively involved in alleviating human suffering, but whether or not the Church should partner with government to accomplish this task. Let me make this point: Those of us who oppose the government solution do so, not because we are indifferent to the suffering of the poor, but because we believe the government will make the situation worse.

Not only do I believe that government intervention will make things worse, I also believe that it robs people of the choice and the opportunity to actually show compassion in a meaningful way. When the government takes money from me through taxes and uses that money to provide something (food, health care, housing) for someone else, I have not shown one ounce of compassion. In other words I have not fulfilled the commandment to love my neighbor. What has happened is that I have been coerced, through the threat of fines and jail time, to part with some of the money I have earned. This is done through taxes. I have no say in how that money will be used, whether it will be used to make bombs or provide food, I simply comply to the demands of the State or face the penalties.*

When the government takes my money, which I have earned by using the talents and opportunities God has given me, it robs me of the choice of how to use that money. I also believe that it prevents me from choosing to show compassion to those in need. Thus the government becomes an obstacle that I have to overcome in order to show real love and compassion to people.

I know what you are thinking, “Steele, you have plenty of money, the government doesn’t take all of your money. You are free to choose to use that money in a compassionate way.” This is true up to a point. There are also the real costs of living to consider and the debts that need to be paid. The reality is that I only have a limited amount of money that the government can be generous with before I become one of those in need.

Sure it would be nice if everyone could have health care coverage, affordable housing, and food to eat, but that is not going to be the reality in this world of sin that we live in. It also needs to be pointed out that the government produces none of these things. For the government to provide for one group of people it must take from another group of people. Do you really want to tell me that is fair? It is wrong for the government to take from me to give to you, even if you are in great need. It is never right to coerce people to do something, even if that something is a good thing. Coercion doesn’t become right just because the government, or even the Church, does it.

Since the government doesn’t produce anything all it can do is coerce people to give what they have produced and give that to someone else. It is impossible to keep taking from one group of people, sooner or later there comes a breaking point. The government can only take so much before those who are being robbed become the very ones who need help.

If you want to follow the way of coercion that is your choice, but I will promise you that it will not lead to the transformation of society you hope to see. The reason it won't lead to transformation is because it is always wrong to take from one person and give to other. Instead of leading to transformation it will lead to resentment and hostility.

The way of transformation is the way of compassion. It happens as individuals choose to give, and at times sacrifice, the blessings God has given to them in order to help those in need. Compassion transforms the person who gives, and provides the opportunity for the person who receives to be transformed as well.

Jesus taught that at the final judgment it would be our individual acts of compassion that would identify us as being part of His kingdom. Consider what Jesus said about the righteous:
“Then the righteous will answer him, saying, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you drink? And when did we see you a stranger and welcome you, or naked and clothe you? And when did we see you sick or in prison and visit you?’ And the King will answer them, ‘Truly, I say to you, as you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me.’” (Matthew 25: 37-40; ESV)

Notice that the righteous choose to show individual and simple acts of compassion. We need to remember that at its core the problem of suffering are individual people who are in desperate need, and at the end of the day no amount of money is going to make a difference. That is why the personal component is so important, and no government program or agency can offer real compassion.

It is interesting to note that these people were not out to serve Jesus by serving people, but rather they were simply being themselves. The righteous had been so transformed by the love of God and so given over to following Jesus that showing compassion was actually part of their nature. May I become that type of person. So in the end the righteous served, not because they were coerced but because they were moved by compassion. It is that reality that revealed them as true citizens of the Kingdom.

* I am not against paying taxes. The government is necessary and there are certain functions that it needs perform. I would also point out that when the government can raise our taxes at will then we are under a form of tyranny that our founding fathers never intended us to accept.

Tuesday, August 04, 2009

The Answer is not the Government

One thing that ticks me off is when people want to use the name of Christ Jesus to promote bad public policy. I noticed this happening today on Facebook. Christians, who have the best intentions, will remind us that Jesus wants us to help the poor, and so we should support health care reform coming out of Washington. The question I want us to consider is this: Is government the means Jesus wants us to help the poor?

Let me be clear on this point. Our national and state government have a role to play in helping people in need, but that does not abdicate the Church from helping the poor. The Church’s position should not be, “Let the government handle it.” Instead our response to the need in the world should be, “What can we do to help?”

The reason I think national health care reform is a bad idea is not because I don’t want to help needy people, but because I think it will harm the poor more than it will help them. Government has a terrible track record effectively running anything. Look at the quality of education in this country or the fact that social programs like Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid are nearing bankruptcy and tell me you really trust the federal government to run a national health insurance program that will actually work.

Besides our government’s incompetence at running supposedly vital programs there is one other truth we have to consider: ALL governments are corrupt. True, some are more corrupt than others, but that does not mean that the government of the United States is innocent. The fact that our bloated government has so often ignored the Constitution, the very law of our nation, tells us that we are dealing with a corrupt government. Since it is corrupt that means health care reform has less to do with helping people in need than it does with consolidating more power. Trust me on this, the powers that be are using the poor to get more power.

The biggest problem of letting the government take care of the needy is that it allows us, the Church of Jesus Christ, to ignore the pain and suffering which exists in this broken and fallen world. We are able to turn a blind eye to what is going on and tell ourselves that someone else is taking care of it. The more government gets involved the less involved Christians will be, and Christians need to be involved in order to truly help people.

Instead of inviting government in to fix the problem we should be insist that the government get less and less involved so people, the true innovators and conduits of compassion can be unleashed on the world. This used to be true. When this country first started it was the Church who started schools and colleges so people could receive an education. Christians started hospitals to minister to the sick. Local churches helped feed the poor by establishing soup kitchens and food pantries. This says nothing of the reality of Christians who every day dug into their pockets to help their neighbors in need.

Then the government got involved and pushed away the Church by making laws which made it more difficult for ordinary people and churches to help in a real way. I know this a simplistic explanation of things, but there is truth to it. When the government gets involved it becomes harder to actually help people in a real and beneficial way.

Followers of Jesus Christ have a personal obligation to help the poor, the sick, and the helpless. We are called to minister to their physical needs. It is interesting to note that many times when Jesus entered a village He took the time to heal people. Caring for the physical needs of people helps establish a relationship with them. Having a relationship with a person is essential for us to accomplish our second obligation to those in need: caring for their spiritual needs. Jesus didn’t just come to heal the sick, feed the hungry, and comfort the lonely, but He came to preach the Gospel. What is the Gospel? Let me tell you what it is not. The Gospel is not that if we accept Jesus as Savior we go to heaven when we die. The Gospel is much grander than that.

The Gospel Jesus preached was: “Repent, for the Kingdom of God is at hand” (Mark 1:14, 15). The Gospel of Christ Jesus is that God is breaking into this world, that creation will be restored, wrongs are going to be made right, and all those who renounce their loyalty to the kingdom of this world and declare loyalty to the King Jesus have a part to play in God’s Kingdom. The Gospel isn’t that we have life after we die, it is that we life right now. That is what people need to hear.

This isn’t just a message people need to hear, but it is a Gospel we need to live. If we live out the Gospel of Christ Jesus then there is no need for the government to get involved in caring for people in need, because they will just mess things up. The answer to our health care crisis is not more government, but less government so Christians can actually live out the Gospel. The answer is not the government, but the answer is the Church. Only the Church can bring the restorative power of God into this world.

Thursday, November 20, 2008

The Price of Ignorance

Cal Thomas has a column today at Townhall.com in which he comments on Intercollegiate Studies Institute study which showed a significant number of Americans could not pass a 33-question Civic Test. What is Civics? Civics is the study of the rights and duties of citizenship. In other words many Americans don't understand what it means to be a citizen. Considering the implications of this Thomas writes:
Ignorance of America's history and heritage is a setup for politicians and others who want to manipulate us into a way of thinking that allows them to make decisions that are unconstitutional and unwise. More than repeating phrases and figures, knowledge of the past prepares us for a future based on unchanging principles. That's why knowledge matters and ignorance endangers our government and threatens our way of life even more than terrorism.
I would encourage you to read the rest of the column: The Other Deficit.

This is also an illustration about what happens when we allow government to run vital institutions: they break them. Do we really want government doing to health care what it has already done to education? Ignorance has a steep cost, and that cost is the gradual loss of our liberties.

Tuesday, November 04, 2008

When The Smoke Clears

{Colossians 1:15-20; ESV}
He is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation. For by him all things were created, in heaven and on earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or dominions or rulers or authorities—all things were created through him and for him. And he is before all things, and in him all things hold together. And he is the head of the body, the church. He is the beginning, the firstborn from the dead, that in everything he might be preeminent. For in him all the fullness of God was pleased to dwell, and through him to reconcile to himself all things, whether on earth or in heaven, making peace by the blood of his cross.

There are certain times in our lives when it is important for us to step back and look at the big picture. As followers of Christ Jesus we need to remember the reason for our hope. Our hope isn’t in our country, our government, a political party, or even a particular candidate. It is easy to get caught up in the rhetoric and begin to believe that one candidate will lead us to a glorious new future and the other will destroy our liberties. Election day becomes judgment day and our hope rests on the results.

I want to encourage us today, especially me since I see both presidential candidates as horrible choices, that regardless of the outcome Jesus is still in control. He is still the Firstborn among the dead, the Head of the church, and the Creator of all things. When the smoke clears the leadership of our government may have changed, and with it a great deal of uncertainty, but Christ Jesus will still be Lord.

Last night as I was laying in bed, trying to get to sleep, I read 1 Peter. In this letter the apostle Peter wrote: Live as people who are free, not using your freedom as a cover-up for evil, but living as servants of God (1 Peter 2:16; ESV). Our freedoms are not gifts from the government, but from God. Peter wants us to live as free people live and in the process serve God. This is what we are required to do no matter who is president or what type of government we live under. Because Jesus is Lord let us live as free people live.

Sunday, November 02, 2008

The End of Democracy

Over at Townhall.com Terry Paulson has an insightful column. Here is a taste of what he wrote:
In America, all citizens are guaranteed "the pursuit of happiness," not happiness given to them by a controlling government. Democrats would have you believe that every American is entitled to full healthcare, welfare, and high wages whether they've earned it or not. And, of course, who is supposed to pay for all these entitlements, those greedy, "wealthy" Americans who already pay most of the taxes! Will Rogers said it years ago, "I remember back when a liberal was someone who was generous with his own money."
I urge you to check out the rest of the column: Democracies Die

Saturday, October 25, 2008

The Cost of Paperwork

Do you wonder why medical care is so expensive? Consider what Philip Howard wrote in The Death of Common Sense. Talking about all the paperwork that comes with governmental regulations Howard writes:
The medical care industry is the hardest hit. Everything—every aspirin, every simple lab test—requires that a form be filled out. How else, the theory goes, can we assure that everything is in order? But hospitals now spend on the order of 25 percent of their budget of administration, mainly to comply with these procedural requirements. The machines that bind the forms at Columbia Presbyterian Hospital in New York City can no longer accommodate an average patient file. In the middle of a medical care crisis, it is unsettling to consider all the time spent by doctors, nurses, and staff on paperwork. Supposedly, the goal is to make sure that money isn’t squandered, but the process itself squanders the money. Forty percent of all doctors say they would not choose the profession again, the main reason being “the ‘hassle factor’—the growing levels of paperwork.” (pp. 93-94)


One of the things that is absolutely killing the United States is regulation. It increases the cost and reduces the quality. Medical care and education are two examples that we are able to encounter on a regular basis. The more government gets involved, the worse off we will be.

Saturday, February 02, 2008

Forced Compassion

What is the role of government? This is a very important question for us to consider and to answer for the answer will determine who we vote for and what programs the government should be offering. Being a Christian and an American there are two sources which will help us determine what the role of government should be. The first is the Bible. In Romans Paul writes:
1 Every person must be subject to the governing authorities, for no authority exists except by God's permission. The existing authorities have been established by God, 2 so that whoever resists the authorities opposes what God has established, and those who resist will bring judgment on themselves.

3 For the authorities are not a terror to good conduct, but to bad. Would you like to live without being afraid of the authorities? Then do what is right, and you will receive their approval. 4 For they are God's servants working for your good. But if you do what is wrong, you should be afraid, for it is not without reason that they bear the sword. Indeed, they are God's servants to execute wrath on anyone who does wrong. 5 Therefore, it is necessary for you to be subject, not only because of God's wrath but also because of your own conscience.

6 This is also why you pay taxes. For rulers are God's servants faithfully devoting themselves to their work. 7 Pay everyone whatever you owe them—taxes to whom taxes are due, tolls to whom tolls are due, fear to whom fear is due, honor to whom honor is due. (Romans 13:1-7, ISV)
According to Paul the basic role government is to play in our lives is law and order. To protect its citizens from criminals on the inside and enemies on the outside. It is for this most basic service that Paul says we pay taxes.

As an American the Constitution of the United States also plays a role in helping us decide what the role of government should be. In fact that is the purpose of the document, yet it is so surprising that so many people in this country have not a single clue what it says. It defines the role of the federal government, which is very limited. If you haven't read the Constitution of this great republic then you should take the time and read it.

One of the things that worries me are Christians, mainly seen in the emergent church, who believe it is the government's role to force people to be compassionate. In other words they believe the government should take my money and give it to somebody who doesn't have any. This is seen in different welfare type programs. This isn't compassion. It is simply redistributing wealth. The way of Jesus is not forced charity but the personal choice to be compassionate.

The problem with forced compassion is that it doesn't work. It doesn't work in a Christian sense or an economic sense. Let us think about this from an economic sense first. The federal government has no money. The money that the government has it takes from people. This is a proper government function. Taxes are not immoral. So the problem isn't with taxes, but with how much money government takes from us and what that money is intended to be used for.

Each "charitable" government program costs money. Something like universal health care costs us money, it isn't free. The more government programs we have the more taxes that are required of us. The heavier the tax burden the less buying power we have as people. The less buying power we have as individuals the worse the economy becomes and the more people there are who need to have government assistance. The more people on government assistance the more taxes that are needed to fund those programs and the heavier the tax burden becomes. In the end we discover forced charity is no charity at all and cannot be sustained, at least not without a crippling tax burden on hard working people (is it moral to tax people so much that they can hardly afford to live?).

Add up the costs of the new programs people like Senators Obama, Clinton, and McCain want to add to an already bloated system and one has to wonder where the money is going to come from. Especially when we think about the reality that we are already borrowing 3 billion a day from places like China. By borrowing money to pay for compassionate social programs we are leaving the next generation to pay the bill. For the sake of the nation our government cannot afford to be the world's largest charity.

I also have a hard time believing that Jesus would what us to give away our responsibility to be charitable by giving that responsibility to the government. We cannot learn to have compassion and to give generously if we think that is the reason we have government. Compassion is a personal choice and charity is a personal responsibility. Remember Jesus' story about judgment in Matthew 25? What separated the righteous form the unrighteous? They were separated by their willingness to help those in need. Let me be absolutely clear on this: We need to fight for justice, stand up for the weak, and help those in need and we lose something when we give this responsibility to the government.

Let me leave you with an illustration. Imagine I was in downtown Chicago and I saw a homeless man on the street and I said to myself: "That man needs to be helped." But I didn't have any money on me so I wondered what I should do. Then I see you. I go over and beat you up, take your money, and give the man all the money in your wallet and say, "Have a good day and God bless." Have I acted compassionately? Have you acted compassionately? When we expect the government to be the source of charity we in essence give them the right to do just that: steal from people who have money and give that money to people who have none. Compassion doesn't happen when we give government the responsibility to help people, but perhaps we ease our consciences by telling ourselves something is being done.

Kept for Christ: Contend for the Faith

This week’s post, based on my June 29 sermon, explores Jude 1:1–4 and the urgent call to defend the faith in a time of spiritual compromise....