Pages

Showing posts with label Richard Dawkins. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Richard Dawkins. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 10, 2009

Religiously Biased Thoughts on The God Delusion #4

Today I return to Richard Dawkins’ best selling book The God Delusion to offer more of my reactions to what he wrote. Chapter 3 of The God Delusion is Dawkins’ dissection of the “positive arguments” for God’s existence. The good professor pulls out 8 different “proofs” and then explains why each one is silly and should be ignored.

It is tempting to get caught up with trying to argue with Dawkins on this point. As Vox Day in The Irrational Atheist points out, “They are tempting honey-traps in which the Dawkins critic is all too easily caught; because Dawkins is convinced that God almost certainly does not exist, attempting to engage him in a reasonable discussion of theological proofs is like trying to mathematically prove the speed of the Earth’s rotation to someone who does not believe in numbers, and furthermore, is utterly convinced that the Earth is a disc mounted on the back of a very large turtle” (p. 138). The same can be said for any Dawkins Groupies that troll the internet looking for a good debate; you are not going to prove God to them.

Instead of proving that these arguments have validity, and I am not convinced that all of them do, I want to focus on how Dawkins is intellectually dishonest in his presentation of these arguments. He either uses arguments that Christians no longer use or he frames them in a way that misrepresent what Christians really believe.

The first argument that Dawkins mentions is the list of five proofs given by Thomas Aquinas. One of the interesting things that Dawkins does here is that he restates the five proofs in his own words rather than directly quoting what Aquinas wrote. So the reader miss the entire impact of Aquinas’ argument, and this is especially significant when it comes to proof 5, the argument from purposeful design, which Dawkins observes is the only one still in use today (p. 103, paperback edition). The reason I think this is significant is because what Aquinas writes in the fifth proof is the basis of the very science Dawkins loves so much. It is because Christians believed that there is a purpose behind creation and that there are natural laws that govern how things work, that caused them to explore the the mechanisms of the world.

One other thing I would mention about the five proofs is that Thomas Aquinas didn’t regard them as proofs in the way that we understand proofs. Alister McGrath wrote, “Although these cannot be regarded as ‘proofs’ in the strict sense of the word, Aquinas regards them as demonstrating the consistency of Christian theology with the known world” (p. 17, The Christian Theology Reader). When we look at the universe through the lens of faith we discover that there is validity, even today, in what Aquinas wrote.

What I find interesting about Anselm’s Ontological Argument (the second argument Dawkins brings up), which formulated in 1079, is that it has never been a serious argument for God’s existence. A German monk by the name of Gaunilo argued against the argument by the end of the eleventh century. While Anselm’s argument is an interesting side note in theology, it hasn’t been used as a real argument for God’s existence, and yet it is the one he spends the most time on. One has to wonder, “If this is such an ‘infantile argument’ why spend six and half pages on it?” Could it be that Dawkins is bothered by it more than the others (which would explain why he spends an equal amount of time on the argument from admired religious scientists)?

The third argument is the argument from beauty. While I think this is a weak argument, it does get a person to wonder, “Why am I so moved by….( a sunset, a love song, the mountains, a good book, a beautiful woman, a brilliant painting)?”

The argument form personal “experience” is the fourth argument that Dawkins mentions. One of the things I find interesting about this argument, which is an observation that Vox Day made as well, is that while Dawkins is the one who put scare quotes around the word experience, The God Delusion is primarily about his personal experience. He references his personal experience more often in the book to make a point than he does empirical evidence. So he is in favor of personal experience when it serves his cause.

Though I realize that isn’t what he means by personal “experience.” What Dawkins refers to here are people who claim to have had a supernatural encounter that led them to believe, such as a vision. While I believe that God gives people dreams and visions, it isn’t what many of us mean when we say that we believe in God because of experience. While I can say that I have had a couple of supernatural encounters in my life they are not part of the personal experience that has led me to have faith in God. My personal experience mainly consists of my observation of faithful people, how living out Jesus’ teaching has made a difference in my life, and the way the Bible has shaped my understanding of the world. It is easy to explain away a person’s experience when it is only understood as the supernatural, but it is harder to explain away when it is what we live everyday of our lives.

The fifth argument is the argument from Scripture. First, it needs to be pointed out that people aren’t convinced of God’s existence because we say, “It is in the Bible.” Scripture is not proof that God exists, though the truth that it contains does lead people to faith.

What Dawkins did with this argument is that he takes the pronouncement of one set of scholars who have said that the Bible is unreliable and leaves it at that. This is what he writes, “Ever since the nineteenth century, scholarly theologians have made an overwhelming case that the gospels are not reliable accounts of what happened in the history of the real world” (p. 118). First, he states that “scholarly theologians” have made the case, and so he implies that anyone who makes a different case is not scholarly. That is disingenuous, because there are very scholarly theologians who would kindly explain to Dawkins why he is mistaken about the reliability of the Bible. Second, he tells us that it is “an overwhelming case,” and so he implies that the other side doesn’t have any evidence worth considering. Given the large amount of manuscript evidence and some solid archeological evidence I think there are some good reasons why we should consider the other side of the argument.

The previously mentioned argument from admired religious scientists compromise the sixth argument. This is another weak argument, but one of the things Dawkins tries to do here is to say the famous religious scientists of the past would have been atheists if they were alive today. It was their culture rather than their study of science that gave them Christian faith. An interesting argument, but also unprovable.

The often referred to Pascal’s Wager is the seventh argument. This is an argument that is misunderstood by both Christians who use it and atheists who mock it. The Catholic philosopher Peter Kreeft has an essay on Pascal’s Wager in his book Fundamentals of the Faith that is well worth the read (the essay and the book).

The last argument is the Bayesian Arguments which is based on Bayes Theorem. Dawkins says that it is the oddest case he has seen to prove God’s existence, and since I had never heard of it before it isn’t worth talking about. Though one of Dawkins criticisms of Stephen Unwin, who put forth the argument in a book entitled The Probability of God, is that Unwin used numbers based on his personal judgments to put into the mathematical formula. I bring this up because we discover Dawkins doing the very same thing in the next chapter, but that discussion will have to wait until next time.

Wednesday, June 03, 2009

Religiously Biased Thoughts on The God Delusion #3

Prayer. It is something that is greatly misunderstood by Christians, atheists, and everyone in between. That is why it is not a shock to find Richard Dawkins commenting on a prayer experiment done by the Templeton Foundation on pages 85-90 of The God Delusion. Dawkins ends his comments with a bit of mockery writing; “Yeah, right: we know from our faith that prayer works, so if evidence fails to show it we’ll just soldier on until finally we get the result we want” (p. 90).

First of all, I want to point out the complete insanity of trying to do an experiment to see if prayer works. I have written about this topic before in a post entitled Testable Prayers. Performing experiments to see if prayer works reeks of all the people who came to Jesus and demanded that He perform some sign for them so they would believe. This is what Jesus told them; “Why do these people keep demanding a miraculous sign? I tell you the truth, I will not give this generation any such sign” (Mark 8:12; NLT). Prayer ceases to be prayer when it is said in the spirit of trying to get God to do your bidding. We shouldn’t expect God to do anything in those situations.

Second, I want to mention our complete misunderstanding of the purpose of prayer. The purpose of prayer isn’t to convince God to provide for us the good life, but it is to usher in the Kingdom of God. Remember the model prayer Jesus gave to us (Matthew 6:9-13)? We can break this model prayer down into three parts. The first part is praise. Jesus shows us that our prayers should start with praising and thanking God for who He is and what He has done. When we open with praise we orient our focus on God. The second part of the prayer could be labeled priorities. Jesus instructs us to pray for God’s will to be done on earth as it is in heaven and that His kingdom comes. Each one of us have our own agenda when it comes to life and ministry, but Jesus reminds us that what matters most is God’s will and His Kingdom. The last part could be called provision. It is here that we focus on our needs. First, there are our physical needs, our daily bread. Second, there are our spiritual needs, forgiveness and deliverance. Here is my point: when we align our priorities with God’s priorities our understanding of what we need for life will change. Our prayers will be more about advancing God’s kingdom than about curing grandma’s bunion.

Third, I know that prayer works, but I have no evidence that prayer works. What evidence can I offer to show that when I ask for wisdom as I am working on a sermon that God grants me wisdom? I know He does, but I have no proof. This is the problem with prayer, unless you experience there is no proof that it happened. Take for example Jesus turning water into wine, after the miracle happened what was the proof that it had happened outside of the testimony of a few people? The same is true for answered prayer. Outside of the testimony of a few people who have experienced it, what is the proof that God acted? That is why answered prayer is an unconvincing argument for unbelievers.

Let people like Richard Dawkins mock us for praying. Proving to them that prayers make a difference in our lives will not change their opinion or bring them to faith. Saving faith has never been built on miracles and signs, but rather it is built on the example of other Christians and a commitment to God’s Word. Instead of trying to convince them that prayer works we should focus on living faithful lives, because in the end it is the faithful life that is the best evidence for the working of prayer and God’s existence.

Thursday, May 28, 2009

Religiously Biased Thoughts on The God Delusion #2

On page 77 of The God Delusion (the paperback edition) Richard Dawkins repeats a strategy used by many other atheists. Dawkins writes, “I have found it an amusing strategy, when asked whether I am an atheist, to point out that the question is also an atheist when considering Zeus, Apollo, Amon, Ra, Mithras, Baal, Thor, Wotan, the Golden Calf and the Flying Spaghetti Monster. I just go one god further.” I will give Dawkins credit that this is the best form of the argument that I have run across, but he is not correct, at least not for an authentic follower of Jesus.

I am not an atheist when it comes to other gods. The reason is because I believe that there are spiritual beings that are at work in this world trying to deceive people and steal their worship. The apostle Paul is states that Satan is the “prince of this world” and that “he is the spirit at work” in the hearts of people to cause them to disobey God (Ephesians 2:2; NLT). Also in Ephesians Paul tells us that our fight is not against other humans, but it is against “the evil rulers and authorities of the unseen world, against those mighty powers of darkness who rule this world, and against wicked spirits in the heavenly realms” (Eph. 6:12; NLT).

Dawkins, like other atheists who use this strategy, confuses worship and belief. I believe in different spiritual beings that are indirectly worshiped by people. This is why I am not surprised that worshipers of other religions have intense spiritual experiences (what better why to deceive people and keep them for Christ Jesus?). Since I have a believe in the supernatural I am not an atheist when it comes to other gods.

I might believe in numerous little gods, but I worship the one true God, who is both the Creator and the Savior. It is our worship and our commitment that God desires, not our belief. God isn’t interested in a Kingdom populated with people who believe in Him, but He desires a Kingdom populated with people who are absolutely committed to Him and worship Him alone. There is a huge difference between belief and worship. Atheism requires the absence of belief as well as the absence of worship. I do not worship all the small gods that exist, but I certainly believe that they exist. That means I am not an atheist on any level.

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Religiously Biased Thoughts on The God Delusion #1

I have been reading through Richard Dawkins’ best selling book The God Delusion. Why did I decide to read a book by the leading face of atheism? One reason I thought it was important for me to read The God Delusion is because I know that it has been a book which has influenced a few of my friends, and so I really needed to know what Dawkins writes in order to have conversations with them. A second reason I am reading the book is because this summer I am doing a class on doubt and faith, and I thought it was important to think through some different objections to faith and God.

One positive thing I can say about the book is that Richard Dawkins is easy to read. I read 222 pages of the paperback edition in two days, and that was with taking time to think through a few things. Which is another positive of the book is that it does move you to consider why you believe what you believe. So I don’t consider my time spent reading the book a waste, but in some small way it has actually been beneficial.

That in no way means that he presents a convincing argument. There has been no point in the book, and I have already read through his “irrefutable argument” for God’s probable non-existence, when I thought my faith in God was threatened. I have found enough holes in his argument to make me doubt his conclusion. What I hope to do over the next few days is to draw your attention to some of these holes.

The first “hole” that I encountered was when Dawkins moves to talk about how the United States was founded as a secular nation (pp. 60-68, paperback edition). In a sense he is correct. The United States was founded as a secular nation because the government is by the people and for the people and not by the church for the people. The nations of Europe had experienced years of problems because the church got involved in government, which is never a good mix. The settlers in America wanted to escape those problems, and were very intentional about making sure that there wouldn’t be that same kind of unhealthy mix in the new country they were creating.

Where Dawkins misses the boat is that the founders believed in the fundamental right of religion. One way we can see this belief (even though a handful of the founders were deists) is in the proclamation of God in the founding documents and on the monuments of the revolution. These men, even the deists, believed that our rights were given to us by God almighty and that shaped the type of government they created.

A second way we see that the founders believed that religion is a fundamental human right is the fact that it is the very first right mentioned in the Bill of Rights. The first ten amendments to the Constitution were added to protect the fundamental rights of people from the power of the federal government. The first amendment, which we often associate with the freedom of speech reads; “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…” It is my suggestion that the founders believed in the absolute necessity of religion for successful existence of the country they were creating. Just as freedom of speech, of the press, of assembly, and petition are crucial elements for a strong a free society, so is the proper expression of religion. Consider what John Adams said:
"We have no government armed with power capable of contending with human passions unbridled by morality and religion. Avarice, ambition, revenge, or gallantry, would break the strongest cords of our Constitution as a whale goes through a net. Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other."


One can see the difference between a government created for a moral and religious people and government created on the basis of Enlightment principles is by looking at the outcomes of the American Revolution and the French Revolution. It seems to me that the founding fathers of the United States understood the value of religion in the lives of the country’s citizens and that is one of the factors that shaped this great nation.

On page 67 of The God Delusion Dawkins suggests that the founding fathers “would have been horrified” by the current political climate. He is absolutely right about that, but not for the reason he thinks. The founders would not be horrified because politicians invoke God and morality in arguing that abortion is wrong or that marriage should be between a man and a woman. They would be horrified because the enormous and abusive power the federal government now has. It is not religion that would bother them, but how we have wasted the great gift they gave to us.

Kept for Christ: Contend for the Faith

This week’s post, based on my June 29 sermon, explores Jude 1:1–4 and the urgent call to defend the faith in a time of spiritual compromise....